Here are the two recipes I used: Bobby Flay's and Cake Man Raven's. I added a little extra cocoa to Cake Man Raven's based on the reviewers on the food network website. I also let both cakes sit in the fridge overnight before the first taste test on the advice of reviewers.
As I am not a master chef, some mishaps occurred during baking. Like a piece of cake falling off as I flipped one of the layers onto the cooling rack. Luckily this only happened on one of the four layers I made and it's easily disguised by massive amounts of frosting!
After making the cakes, I had everyone I could sample them (including myself of course). I brought them to our neighbors, coworkers and family members. Everyone was extremely cooperative (Generally no one ever says no to the question: "Can you help me taste test these cakes?")Then we tallied up the votes.
Many people liked the flavor of Bobby Flay's cake more. However several people preferred the cream cheese frosting that Cake Man put with his cake. Cake Man's cake was also moister. Most people viewed the Cake Man's as more traditional, and saw Bobby Flay's as a new spin on things (I have no idea if this is true). It was a very close race. One of my favorite parts was hearing every one's detailed analysis of the cakes (Cake tasting is serious business!) So what's my verdict? I say the winner is the Cake Man! The moistness of the cake combined with the overall presentation won me over. Not that the other cake wasn't delicious. In fact I felt a little bad because I think it was a bit more competetive on the first day; I don't think Bobby Flay's did as well in the fridge.
That's it! It was a fun experiment! I'd love to do it again, although not with red velvet for awhile (trust me that much cake with only three people in the house was never ending!).
The two finished cakes side by side!
Currently watching: Community Reruns and SYTYCD